Jump to a review by selecting a manufacturer and a model.
Or just select a manufacturer to see reviews of all of their cameras.
Step 1 MANUFACTURER
Select a manufacturer
Step 2 CAMERA MODEL
Select a camera model
Step 3 SEARCH CAMERAS
Search the database

You know how much you want to spend on your
next camera, so tell us and we'll show you the options.
Select a price range and a type of camera and hit Search.
Step 1 PRICE RANGE
Select your price range
Step 2 CAMERA TYPE
Select a camera type
Step 3 SEARCH CAMERAS
Search the database
home | about | glossary | faqs | reviewers | podcasts | rss | forum | contact | advertise | suggest
Compare
Compare up to four cameras by clicking on the icons next to them. They will be stored up here.
Compare

Compare

The camera has been added to the comparisons bar at the top of the page
Don't show this message again
Camera Search

Nikon AF-S Nikkor 16-85mm f4G ED VR

DATE REVIEWED: 13th Apr 2010

Lens Overview

Lens Type Wide Focal Length16 - 85mm
RRP£500 Aperturef4 - 22
FittingsNAF Focus Distance 0.28cm - inf
Filter Size77 Diameter82mm
Weight685g Length125mm

Gallery

Review

Return to Latest Lenses »

This is not Nikon’s first ultra-wide FX zoom. When the full-frame D3 body was launched Nikon also introduced the spectacular 14-24mm f2.8, a lens so good that this 16-35mm actually has quite a tough act to follow.

Perhaps the biggest problem with the existing 14-24mm, though is its cost. With a list price of over £1500, it’s a serious investment. It’s also a big, ungainly lens, and unlike this new model, it doesn’t have VR.

On paper, then, the new 16-35mm is an attractive alternative. It’s cheaper and lighter, and although the maximum aperture is lower at f4 versus f2.8, the Vibration Reduction system should make up for that. Perhaps its biggest advantage, is its focal length range. It doesn’t go quite as wide as the 14-24mm, but with a maximum focal length of 35mm, it’s just that little bit more versatile as a ‘walk around’ lens.

But all these advantages are relative. With a length of 125mm and a weight of 685g, this is still a big lens. It has the characteristic ‘trumpet’ shape of Nikon’s latest FX zooms: long and fat at the front and narrower where it fixes to the body. The extra length means that there’s plenty of space for the zoom and focus rings, though, so if you don’t mind the bulk you’ll find this an easy lens to handle.

Zooming and focusing are both internal. This means the length doesn’t change as you zoom and there are no extending barrels. Filters won’t rotate as you focus, either, though the lens’s extreme viewing angle means you’ll need to use a super-wideangle filter mount. It beats the 14-24mm, though, which has a permanent lens hood and wildly convex front element that defeats conventional filter systems altogether.

When you add this to the VR system, you’ve got a lens which doesn’t necessarily match the extreme performance of the older 14-24mm, but which could prove more practical in everyday use.

It’s still not cheap, but in this territory optical quality does cost a lot of money. You could look at Sigma’s rather amazing 12-24mm lens, which isn’t much more than half the price and goes wider than either of Nikon’s ultra-wideangles. It’s a few years old now, though, and unproven on the latest generation of full-frame DSLRs. Or you could take a look at Nikon’s older 18-35mm zoom, which sells for around £500 and is much smaller and lighter, though its design dates back to Nikon’s film cameras when know-how and expectations were lower.

Final Verdict
The 16-35mm is not as ‘extreme’ as Nikon’s 14-24mm, but it is cheaper and rather more practical for everyday use.
OVERALL
SHARE THIS ARTICLE

Reviewer Profile



Rod Lawton

Our lens reviewer, and technical expert, Rod is a veritable photographic encyclopaedia. His illustrious CV has seen him write for many mags, websites and journals.

Total Camera Reviews 7
Average Camera Rating 4.1
Rod's Last 5 Reviews
Olympus XZ-1 5 / 5
Canon PowerShot SX1 IS 5 / 5
Casio Exilim EX-FH20 4 / 5
Olympus µ-1050 SW 3 / 5
Panasonic Lumix DMC-LX3 4 / 5
Click here to view Rod's profile »
Digital Photographer Latest Uploaded Photos
Click an image below to view or Click here for the Digital Photographer website.
Join The Community
Clock Tower - Palace of Westminster The Balance Returning home Gateway to Winnats From an Angle Unni-que Snowy Vista The more the silence, the more we can hear San Francisco Art Baby Blue eyes. Bat Girl Off-gaurd Sadness. Balloons Heaven and Earth Tiger 2 Tiger 1 Dear In The Undergrowth Sunset at Melkbosstrand Are You Looking At Me? Staying Ahead B&W Big Buddha Doggy Talk. Anger. Aurora borealis Aged and decayed Extinguisher, in colour Decay in progress Seashore of Norway Autumn reflections Autumn colors Yellow Flower Foggy Harbour 2 Foggy Harbour Arria Mono Canal Paige_1 Troubled Skies Dead Sea Ignis Top Light